By Dr Srinivansan Ramasamy, Director, Biological Sciences Research Program & Lead Entomologist, WorldVeg
For 50 years, Integrated Pest Management (IPM) has been the holy grail of sustainable crop protection.
And I understand the appeal: Instead of relying on chemical pesticides – jeopardizing both environmental and human health – IPM’s ecosystem-based approach looks to nature to lend a helping hand.
IPM encourages beneficial insects and the use of non-chemical methods to control pests, crop rotation to reduce outbreaks, and nature to do more of the work. Chemical pesticides are used only sparingly.
IPM has received millions of dollars in funding for development and scaling, resulting in countless research publications and generations of capacity-sharing programs. Entire careers have been built around it — mine included.
But here’s the uncomfortable truth: widespread adoption of IPM remains low.
The vast majority of smallholder farmers in low- and middle-income countries continue to rely on calendar-based application of chemical pesticides.
They are trapped in a vicious cycle of dependency: spraying to protect their crops, killing both friendly and unfriendly insects. Then they’re forced to continue spraying to keep the bad bugs at bay. It’s hard to establish an effective IPM strategy in the wake of a generalized insect Armageddon.
Perhaps that’s one reason the global pesticide market grew to almost USD 80 billion by 2021, while biopesticides – natural pest-control products often promoted as part of IPM – though essential, remained only a tiny fraction of it.
In addition, many IPM programs quietly assume farmers have the time and appetite to become part-time entomologists or crop protection specialists. Spoiler alert: most do not.
Farmers generally want the same thing the rest of us want from technology: something simple, affordable, and reliable. Technologies that seem like an additional burden or a financial risk are likely to be rejected.
In addition, focusing on farm-level crop protection can miss the broader market failures that inhibit adoption. Specifically, a lack of affordable, commercialized IPM inputs and an output market that offers no price premiums for IPM-grown crops.
This has led to fatigue among some stakeholders, including some funders.
So I’m sorry, IPM. It’s over.
Instead, we need a new, broader approach: Integrated Plant Health Management, or IPHEM.
Redefining plant protection
For argument’s sake, let’s pronounce it “eye-fem”. Yes, the acronym is clunky. But agricultural research-for-development has a rich history of clunky acronyms.
The idea, however, matters. I wrote about it recently in a Perspective paper in Frontiers in Insect Science.
IPHEM incorporates many essential principles of IPM, but goes much further.
It encourages a shift away from the perpetual firefight against pest and disease outbreaks to a focus on prevention. It aims to strengthen plant health in various ways rather than simply treating problems after they emerge.
That means shifting from reactive approaches – waiting for pests or diseases to exceed economic thresholds before taking action – to proactive ones that optimize inherent plant health and agroecology from the outset.
This begins with the use of resistant crop varieties, quality seeds and healthy seedlings, and other agronomic practices (such as precise water and nutrient management, timely weed control, and the use of mixed, inter-, and relay cropping) to break pest and disease cycles.
These best practices – especially at the early stages of crop production and, in addition to withholding chemical pesticides – will allow the proliferation of beneficial natural enemies on the farm.
This can be followed by the use of biocontrol agents (beneficial organisms that suppress pests and diseases) and biopesticides.
It also permits the careful use of selective chemical pesticides, depending on needs later in the season.
This way, maintaining plant health becomes a routine part of farmers’ standard seasonal workflow rather than an additional burden.
Beyond the farm
Even the best farm-level practices will fail to deliver real economic benefits if specialized inputs are too expensive or the market fails to reward farmers with higher prices for their efforts.
So for IPHEM to be widely adopted, it’s essential to address the food system more broadly. This is where the WorldVeg Push-Pull-Policy Framework comes in, tackling supply, demand, and policy issues simultaneously.
Push (Securing supply): We need to take IPHEM technologies out of the lab and bring them to the market. This involves collaborating with agro-dealers and local input suppliers to develop manufacturing and distribution pipelines for bio-inputs, for example, by providing them with technical blueprints and manufacturing support. This would increase production, reduce unit costs, and ensure that affordable bio-inputs and other IPHEM tools are available and accessible.
Pull (Stimulating demand): We need to increase consumer demand by collaborating with nutrition and health campaigns and consumer advocacy groups to educate the public about the risks associated with chemical residues in their food. This will involve establishing trust, for example, through clear, low-cost labeling systems that support claims such as ‘IPHEM-certified’ or ‘residue-free.’ It might also involve securing dedicated shelf space for certified products in supermarkets and local grocery chains. Doing so could help ensure price premiums and other economic incentives that farmers need to adopt IPHEM practices.
Policy (Fostering governance): We must lobby for a supportive policy environment in which governments stop subsidizing chemical pesticides and instead provide incentives (tax-related or otherwise) for biological inputs for IPHEM.
This could include public procurement rules requiring schools, hospitals, and government offices to source a portion of their food from certified IPHEM farms.
All this requires researchers like me to collaborate across disciplines, for example, with those in agroecology, plant protection, nutrition, and social sciences. That will enable us to co-design IPHEM tools that are appropriate, applicable, and accessible. IPM has already taught us the importance of collaboration; now we need to take that spirit and use it to drive the next generation of agricultural innovation.
Finally, funders will need to direct their investments toward systems that co-develop IPHEM tools, generate market demand, support the commercial agro-input sector, and ensure the production of safer food.
Yes, there are a lot of moving parts.
But if successful, IPHEM could help us bid farewell to farming’s chemical treadmill and establish something much more holistic and resilient.
Even if people do find it hard to pronounce.
